Skip to content

New York data · October 2026

Cattaraugus County, New York property market data

Abunsh scores 26 of the 28 ZIP codes in Cattaraugus County against every US ZIP code for supply, demand, home values, the rental market and the local economy. The Area Score's Economics group uses county figures, so ZIP codes wholly inside Cattaraugus County share them; one that spans counties blends them. The best placed is Delevan 14042, #270 of 1,693 in New York. The typical home value is a median $171,804 across the county's ZIP codes.

ZIP codes

28

26 scored · October 2026

Best Area Score

96.0

Delevan 14042

Typical home value

$172k

Median of ZIP codes · Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,310/mo

Median of ZIP codes · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027)

Top markets in Cattaraugus County

The best-placed ZIP codes with Very High or High confidence, at the default ranking: 5 of 28. Places are within New York.

Delevan 14042: Area Score 96.0Portville 14770: Area Score 95.3Limestone 14753: Area Score 95.1West Valley 14171: Area Score 94.4Conewango Valley 14726: Area Score 93.9South Dayton 14138: Area Score 93.7Hinsdale 14743: Area Score 93.6Cattaraugus 14719: Area Score 93.2Franklinville 14737: Area Score 93.0Olean 14760: Area Score 93.0Machias 14101: Area Score 92.9Farmersville Station 14060: Area Score 91.3Allegany 14706: Area Score 89.4Yorkshire 14173: Area Score 89.2Kill Buck 14748: Area Score 89.0Salamanca 14779: Area Score 88.5Randolph 14772: Area Score 88.2Little Valley 14755: Area Score 87.3Freedom 14065: Area Score 86.6Perrysburg 14129: Area Score 84.6Great Valley 14741: Area Score 78.3East Otto 14729: Area Score 74.7Saint Bonaventure 14778: Area Score 69.6Dayton 14041: Area Score 67.4Westons Mills 14788: Area Score 67.4Ellicottville 14731: Area Score 16.5Versailles 14168: Area Score —Steamburg 14783: Area Score —
Cattaraugus County's ZIP codes in New York, colored by Area Score.
  1. #403Franklinville 14737$160k typical value93.0
  2. #405Olean 14760$124k typical value93.0
  3. #556Allegany 14706$204k typical value89.4
  4. #629Little Valley 14755$178k typical value87.3
  5. #1639Ellicottville 14731$389k typical value16.5

Every ZIP code in Cattaraugus County

Best placed first, each with its Area Score.

  1. #270Delevan 14042$201k typical value96.0
  2. #311Portville 14770$151k typical value95.3
  3. #322Limestone 14753$119k typical value95.1
  4. #350West Valley 14171$230k typical value94.4
  5. #373Conewango Valley 14726$149k typical value93.9
  6. #378South Dayton 14138$150k typical value93.7
  7. #380Hinsdale 14743$155k typical value93.6
  8. #395Cattaraugus 14719$172k typical value93.2
  9. #403Franklinville 14737$160k typical value93.0
  10. #405Olean 14760$124k typical value93.0
  11. #407Machias 14101$207k typical value92.9
  12. #486Farmersville Station 14060$159k typical value91.3
  13. #556Allegany 14706$204k typical value89.4
  14. #571Yorkshire 14173$185k typical value89.2
  15. #575Kill Buck 14748$157k typical value89.0
  16. #595Salamanca 14779$112k typical value88.5
  17. #602Randolph 14772$166k typical value88.2
  18. #629Little Valley 14755$178k typical value87.3
  19. #656Freedom 14065$202k typical value86.6
  20. #725Perrysburg 14129$194k typical value84.6
  21. #893Great Valley 14741$239k typical value78.3
  22. #979East Otto 14729$234k typical value74.7
  23. #1084Saint Bonaventure 1477869.6
  24. =1126Dayton 1404167.4
  25. =1126Westons Mills 1478867.4
  26. #1639Ellicottville 14731$389k typical value16.5
  27. —Versailles 14168—
  28. —Steamburg 14783—

See Cattaraugus County ranked your way

Open New York in Abunsh, weight what matters and every ZIP code is re-scored. Free to start.

Open New York in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Each ZIP code is scored against every US ZIP code; places are within New York. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.