Skip to content

New York data · October 2026

Erie County, New York property market data

Abunsh scores 65 of the 69 ZIP codes in Erie County against every US ZIP code for supply, demand, home values, the rental market and the local economy. The Area Score's Economics group uses county figures, so ZIP codes wholly inside Erie County share them; one that spans counties blends them. The best placed is Depew 14043, #28 of 1,693 in New York. The typical home value is a median $305,506 across the county's ZIP codes.

ZIP codes

69

65 scored · October 2026

Best Area Score

99.7

Depew 14043

Typical home value

$306k

Median of ZIP codes · Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,670/mo

Median of ZIP codes · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027)

Top markets in Erie County

The best-placed ZIP codes with Very High or High confidence, at the default ranking: 12 of 69. Places are within New York.

Depew 14043: Area Score 99.7Buffalo 14221: Area Score 99.3Buffalo 14226: Area Score 99.3Buffalo 14212: Area Score 99.3East Amherst 14051: Area Score 99.1Tonawanda 14150: Area Score 99.0Clarence Center 14032: Area Score 99.0Grand Island 14072: Area Score 98.9Derby 14047: Area Score 98.8Elma 14059: Area Score 98.8Orchard Park 14127: Area Score 98.6Buffalo 14224: Area Score 98.6Buffalo 14210: Area Score 98.6Buffalo 14217: Area Score 98.5Buffalo 14228: Area Score 98.5Buffalo 14227: Area Score 98.5Lake View 14085: Area Score 98.3Angola 14006: Area Score 98.3Getzville 14068: Area Score 98.0Lancaster 14086: Area Score 97.6Buffalo 14223: Area Score 97.5East Aurora 14052: Area Score 97.3Buffalo 14219: Area Score 97.3Hamburg 14075: Area Score 97.0Clarence 14031: Area Score 96.9Buffalo 14216: Area Score 96.8Buffalo 14225: Area Score 96.5Alden 14004: Area Score 96.4Holland 14080: Area Score 94.8Buffalo 14220: Area Score 94.3Buffalo 14218: Area Score 94.0Eden 14057: Area Score 92.9Buffalo 14214: Area Score 92.7Buffalo 14206: Area Score 92.6Akron 14001: Area Score 92.6Springville 14141: Area Score 91.9Buffalo 14211: Area Score 91.6Buffalo 14222: Area Score 91.5Buffalo 14203: Area Score 90.7Boston 14025: Area Score 90.4North Collins 14111: Area Score 90.0Buffalo 14208: Area Score 88.8Lawtons 14091: Area Score 88.7Buffalo 14215: Area Score 85.9Collins 14034: Area Score 84.3Buffalo 14201: Area Score 83.6Irving 14081: Area Score 80.7Buffalo 14207: Area Score 80.4Gowanda 14070: Area Score 77.3Buffalo 14213: Area Score 77.2Colden 14033: Area Score 77.2Chaffee 14030: Area Score 69.0Brant 14027: Area Score 64.8Collins Center 14035: Area Score 64.7Buffalo 14260: Area Score 64.7Bowmansville 14026: Area Score 62.2West Falls 14170: Area Score 61.9South Wales 14139: Area Score 61.5Buffalo 14261: Area Score 57.6Marilla 14102: Area Score 56.3Glenwood 14069: Area Score 55.4Buffalo 14209: Area Score 52.4East Concord 14055: Area Score 51.4Buffalo 14204: Area Score 20.5Buffalo 14202: Area Score 11.4Farnham 14061: Area Score —North Evans 14112: Area Score —Sardinia 14134: Area Score —Wales Center 14169: Area Score —
Erie County's ZIP codes in New York, colored by Area Score.
  1. #28Depew 14043$266k typical value99.7
  2. #67Buffalo 14221$415k typical value99.3
  3. #71Buffalo 14226$312k typical value99.3
  4. #72Buffalo 14212$152k typical value99.3
  5. #81East Amherst 14051$536k typical value99.1
  6. #90Tonawanda 14150$255k typical value99.0
  7. #94Clarence Center 14032$602k typical value99.0
  8. #102Grand Island 14072$388k typical value98.9
  9. #107Derby 14047$251k typical value98.8
  10. #108Elma 14059$423k typical value98.8
  11. #124Orchard Park 14127$432k typical value98.6
  12. #126Buffalo 14224$295k typical value98.6

Every ZIP code in Erie County

Best placed first, each with its Area Score.

  1. #28Depew 14043$266k typical value99.7
  2. #67Buffalo 14221$415k typical value99.3
  3. #71Buffalo 14226$312k typical value99.3
  4. #72Buffalo 14212$152k typical value99.3
  5. #81East Amherst 14051$536k typical value99.1
  6. #90Tonawanda 14150$255k typical value99.0
  7. #94Clarence Center 14032$602k typical value99.0
  8. #102Grand Island 14072$388k typical value98.9
  9. #107Derby 14047$251k typical value98.8
  10. #108Elma 14059$423k typical value98.8
  11. #124Orchard Park 14127$432k typical value98.6
  12. #126Buffalo 14224$295k typical value98.6
  13. #127Buffalo 14210$171k typical value98.6
  14. #129Buffalo 14217$255k typical value98.5
  15. #131Buffalo 14228$352k typical value98.5
  16. #132Buffalo 14227$264k typical value98.5
  17. #140Lake View 14085$367k typical value98.3
  18. #142Angola 14006$226k typical value98.3
  19. #160Getzville 14068$453k typical value98.0
  20. #187Lancaster 14086$381k typical value97.6
  21. #190Buffalo 14223$263k typical value97.5
  22. #205East Aurora 14052$441k typical value97.3
  23. #206Buffalo 14219$256k typical value97.3
  24. #221Hamburg 14075$333k typical value97.0
  25. #227Clarence 14031$517k typical value96.9
  26. #231Buffalo 14216$331k typical value96.8
  27. #246Buffalo 14225$230k typical value96.5
  28. #251Alden 14004$329k typical value96.4
  29. #332Holland 14080$332k typical value94.8
  30. #357Buffalo 14220$227k typical value94.3
  31. #370Buffalo 14218$219k typical value94.0
  32. #410Eden 14057$325k typical value92.9
  33. #418Buffalo 14214$281k typical value92.7
  34. #422Buffalo 14206$171k typical value92.6
  35. #423Akron 14001$316k typical value92.6
  36. #455Springville 14141$256k typical value91.9
  37. #464Buffalo 14211$118k typical value91.6
  38. #468Buffalo 14222$531k typical value91.5
  39. #506Buffalo 1420390.7
  40. #516Boston 14025$350k typical value90.4
  41. #533North Collins 14111$253k typical value90.0
  42. #582Buffalo 14208$142k typical value88.8
  43. #586Lawtons 14091$279k typical value88.7
  44. #680Buffalo 14215$147k typical value85.9
  45. #736Collins 14034$221k typical value84.3
  46. #760Buffalo 14201$309k typical value83.6
  47. #837Irving 14081$243k typical value80.7
  48. #846Buffalo 14207$160k typical value80.4
  49. #915Gowanda 14070$165k typical value77.3
  50. #917Buffalo 14213$195k typical value77.2
  51. #920Colden 14033$379k typical value77.2
  52. #1100Chaffee 14030$254k typical value69.0
  53. #1171Brant 1402764.8
  54. =1172Collins Center 1403564.7
  55. =1172Buffalo 1426064.7
  56. #1216Bowmansville 14026$306k typical value62.2
  57. #1224West Falls 14170$386k typical value61.9
  58. #1229South Wales 14139$362k typical value61.5
  59. #1293Buffalo 1426157.6
  60. #1314Marilla 14102$388k typical value56.3
  61. #1325Glenwood 14069$306k typical value55.4
  62. #1368Buffalo 14209$316k typical value52.4
  63. #1382East Concord 14055$316k typical value51.4
  64. #1619Buffalo 14204$176k typical value20.5
  65. #1662Buffalo 14202$556k typical value11.4
  66. —Farnham 14061—
  67. —North Evans 14112—
  68. —Sardinia 14134$264k typical value—
  69. —Wales Center 14169—

See Erie County ranked your way

Open New York in Abunsh, weight what matters and every ZIP code is re-scored. Free to start.

Open New York in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Each ZIP code is scored against every US ZIP code; places are within New York. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.