Skip to content

New York data · October 2026

Sullivan County, New York property market data

Abunsh scores 48 of the 53 ZIP codes in Sullivan County against every US ZIP code for supply, demand, home values, the rental market and the local economy. The Area Score's Economics group uses county figures, so ZIP codes wholly inside Sullivan County share them; one that spans counties blends them. The best placed is Fallsburg 12733, #550 of 1,693 in New York. The typical home value is a median $319,746 across the county's ZIP codes.

ZIP codes

53

48 scored · October 2026

Best Area Score

89.6

Fallsburg 12733

Typical home value

$320k

Median of ZIP codes · Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,840/mo

Median of ZIP codes · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027)

Top markets in Sullivan County

The best-placed ZIP codes with Very High or High confidence, at the default ranking: 5 of 53. Places are within New York.

Fallsburg 12733: Area Score 89.6Mountain Dale 12763: Area Score 89.1Woodridge 12789: Area Score 86.9Liberty 12754: Area Score 86.0Harris 12742: Area Score 83.4Loch Sheldrake 12759: Area Score 81.4Cochecton 12726: Area Score 79.5White Lake 12786: Area Score 77.9Rock Hill 12775: Area Score 74.3South Fallsburg 12779: Area Score 74.1Kiamesha Lake 12751: Area Score 72.6Bloomingburg 12721: Area Score 72.5Woodbourne 12788: Area Score 72.3Bethel 12720: Area Score 72.0Phillipsport 12769: Area Score 70.0Neversink 12765: Area Score 69.9Lake Huntington 12752: Area Score 69.8Grahamsville 12740: Area Score 69.3Hurleyville 12747: Area Score 68.9Youngsville 12791: Area Score 67.7Pond Eddy 12770: Area Score 67.6Long Eddy 12760: Area Score 67.3Mongaup Valley 12762: Area Score 64.2White Sulphur Springs 12787: Area Score 63.5North Branch 12766: Area Score 63.0Kauneonga Lake 12749: Area Score 61.0Obernburg 12767: Area Score 61.0Summitville 12781: Area Score 61.0Hankins 12741: Area Score 59.5Callicoon 12723: Area Score 59.5Fremont Center 12736: Area Score 59.2Glen Wild 12738: Area Score 59.2Smallwood 12778: Area Score 57.4Highland Lake 12743: Area Score 55.7Monticello 12701: Area Score 55.2Ferndale 12734: Area Score 54.7Livingston Manor 12758: Area Score 53.4Wurtsboro 12790: Area Score 51.7Jeffersonville 12748: Area Score 50.3Narrowsburg 12764: Area Score 48.6Roscoe 12776: Area Score 46.8Parksville 12768: Area Score 45.3Swan Lake 12783: Area Score 42.7Yulan 12792: Area Score 41.8Glen Spey 12737: Area Score 36.9Forestburgh 12777: Area Score 32.5Eldred 12732: Area Score 29.2Barryville 12719: Area Score 20.6Burlingham 12722: Area Score —Callicoon Center 12724: Area Score —Hortonville 12745: Area Score —Kenoza Lake 12750: Area Score —Thompsonville 12784: Area Score —
Sullivan County's ZIP codes in New York, colored by Area Score.
  1. #672Liberty 12754$275k typical value86.0
  2. #1019Bloomingburg 12721$435k typical value72.5
  3. #1330Monticello 12701$290k typical value55.2
  4. #1354Livingston Manor 12758$336k typical value53.4
  5. #1380Wurtsboro 12790$291k typical value51.7

Every ZIP code in Sullivan County

Best placed first, each with its Area Score.

  1. #550Fallsburg 12733$331k typical value89.6
  2. #572Mountain Dale 12763$277k typical value89.1
  3. #644Woodridge 12789$286k typical value86.9
  4. #672Liberty 12754$275k typical value86.0
  5. #763Harris 12742$312k typical value83.4
  6. #816Loch Sheldrake 12759$314k typical value81.4
  7. #864Cochecton 12726$373k typical value79.5
  8. #901White Lake 12786$306k typical value77.9
  9. #991Rock Hill 12775$413k typical value74.3
  10. #993South Fallsburg 12779$299k typical value74.1
  11. #1017Kiamesha Lake 12751$213k typical value72.6
  12. #1019Bloomingburg 12721$435k typical value72.5
  13. #1028Woodbourne 12788$295k typical value72.3
  14. #1037Bethel 12720$331k typical value72.0
  15. #1074Phillipsport 1276970.0
  16. #1076Neversink 12765$299k typical value69.9
  17. #1079Lake Huntington 12752$350k typical value69.8
  18. #1092Grahamsville 12740$295k typical value69.3
  19. #1101Hurleyville 12747$317k typical value68.9
  20. #1119Youngsville 12791$278k typical value67.7
  21. #1122Pond Eddy 12770$317k typical value67.6
  22. =1128Long Eddy 12760$288k typical value67.3
  23. #1180Mongaup Valley 12762$263k typical value64.2
  24. #1191White Sulphur Springs 12787$263k typical value63.5
  25. #1199North Branch 12766$367k typical value63.0
  26. =1243Kauneonga Lake 1274961.0
  27. =1243Obernburg 1276761.0
  28. =1243Summitville 1278161.0
  29. #1264Hankins 12741$336k typical value59.5
  30. #1265Callicoon 12723$371k typical value59.5
  31. #1270Fremont Center 12736$353k typical value59.2
  32. #1271Glen Wild 12738$414k typical value59.2
  33. #1296Smallwood 12778$227k typical value57.4
  34. #1320Highland Lake 12743$413k typical value55.7
  35. #1330Monticello 12701$290k typical value55.2
  36. #1338Ferndale 12734$321k typical value54.7
  37. #1354Livingston Manor 12758$336k typical value53.4
  38. #1380Wurtsboro 12790$291k typical value51.7
  39. #1395Jeffersonville 12748$349k typical value50.3
  40. #1418Narrowsburg 12764$384k typical value48.6
  41. #1435Roscoe 12776$296k typical value46.8
  42. #1447Parksville 12768$316k typical value45.3
  43. #1467Swan Lake 12783$342k typical value42.7
  44. #1474Yulan 12792$325k typical value41.8
  45. #1509Glen Spey 12737$362k typical value36.9
  46. #1543Forestburgh 12777$400k typical value32.5
  47. #1565Eldred 12732$320k typical value29.2
  48. #1616Barryville 12719$375k typical value20.6
  49. —Burlingham 12722—
  50. —Callicoon Center 12724$358k typical value—
  51. —Hortonville 12745—
  52. —Kenoza Lake 12750—
  53. —Thompsonville 12784—

See Sullivan County ranked your way

Open New York in Abunsh, weight what matters and every ZIP code is re-scored. Free to start.

Open New York in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Each ZIP code is scored against every US ZIP code; places are within New York. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.