Skip to content

New York data · October 2026

Ulster County, New York property market data

Abunsh scores 53 of the 56 ZIP codes in Ulster County against every US ZIP code for supply, demand, home values, the rental market and the local economy. The Area Score's Economics group uses county figures, so ZIP codes wholly inside Ulster County share them; one that spans counties blends them. The best placed is Port Ewen 12466, #283 of 1,693 in New York. The typical home value is a median $447,568 across the county's ZIP codes.

ZIP codes

56

53 scored · October 2026

Best Area Score

95.8

Port Ewen 12466

Typical home value

$448k

Median of ZIP codes · Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$2,280/mo

Median of ZIP codes · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027)

Top markets in Ulster County

The best-placed ZIP codes with Very High or High confidence, at the default ranking: 12 of 56. Places are within New York.

Port Ewen 12466: Area Score 95.8Mount Marion 12456: Area Score 86.6Milton 12547: Area Score 84.1Tillson 12486: Area Score 84.1Cragsmoor 12420: Area Score 82.2New Paltz 12561: Area Score 81.9Napanoch 12458: Area Score 81.7Pine Bush 12566: Area Score 80.9Lake Katrine 12449: Area Score 80.6Boiceville 12412: Area Score 79.1Cottekill 12419: Area Score 79.1Wallkill 12589: Area Score 79.0Greenfield Park 12435: Area Score 78.7Stone Ridge 12484: Area Score 78.3Highland 12528: Area Score 77.6Shokan 12481: Area Score 76.0Pine Hill 12465: Area Score 74.4Hurley 12443: Area Score 74.0Shandaken 12480: Area Score 71.9Rosendale 12472: Area Score 71.8Marlboro 12542: Area Score 71.5West Shokan 12494: Area Score 70.9West Park 12493: Area Score 70.5Modena 12548: Area Score 70.0Chichester 12416: Area Score 69.2Kingston 12401: Area Score 68.9Ellenville 12428: Area Score 67.7West Hurley 12491: Area Score 67.3Ruby 12475: Area Score 67.2Connelly 12417: Area Score 66.2Highmount 12441: Area Score 66.0Rifton 12471: Area Score 65.4High Falls 12440: Area Score 63.8Glasco 12432: Area Score 63.8Esopus 12429: Area Score 62.8Big Indian 12410: Area Score 62.8Lake Hill 12448: Area Score 62.5Bloomington 12411: Area Score 62.0Phoenicia 12464: Area Score 61.3Malden On Hudson 12453: Area Score 61.2Claryville 12725: Area Score 60.3Ulster Park 12487: Area Score 59.0Willow 12495: Area Score 56.1Olivebridge 12461: Area Score 54.0Glenford 12433: Area Score 53.4Woodstock 12498: Area Score 53.1Mount Tremper 12457: Area Score 49.8Saugerties 12477: Area Score 48.7Gardiner 12525: Area Score 48.0Clintondale 12515: Area Score 39.9Kerhonkson 12446: Area Score 36.9Accord 12404: Area Score 33.4Bearsville 12409: Area Score 32.0Spring Glen 12483: Area Score —Wawarsing 12489: Area Score —West Camp 12490: Area Score —
Ulster County's ZIP codes in New York, colored by Area Score.
  1. #283Port Ewen 12466$387k typical value95.8
  2. #803New Paltz 12561$541k typical value81.9
  3. #832Pine Bush 12566$446k typical value80.9
  4. #876Wallkill 12589$484k typical value79.0
  5. #892Stone Ridge 12484$592k typical value78.3
  6. #906Highland 12528$433k typical value77.6
  7. #994Hurley 12443$453k typical value74.0
  8. #1046Marlboro 12542$465k typical value71.5
  9. #1102Kingston 12401$395k typical value68.9
  10. #1120Ellenville 12428$302k typical value67.7
  11. #1345Olivebridge 12461$547k typical value54.0
  12. #1357Woodstock 12498$659k typical value53.1

Every ZIP code in Ulster County

Best placed first, each with its Area Score.

  1. #283Port Ewen 12466$387k typical value95.8
  2. #649Mount Marion 12456$271k typical value86.6
  3. #743Milton 12547$471k typical value84.1
  4. #747Tillson 12486$428k typical value84.1
  5. #791Cragsmoor 12420$503k typical value82.2
  6. #803New Paltz 12561$541k typical value81.9
  7. #806Napanoch 12458$294k typical value81.7
  8. #832Pine Bush 12566$446k typical value80.9
  9. #841Lake Katrine 12449$360k typical value80.6
  10. #872Boiceville 12412$438k typical value79.1
  11. #874Cottekill 12419$525k typical value79.1
  12. #876Wallkill 12589$484k typical value79.0
  13. #885Greenfield Park 12435$387k typical value78.7
  14. #892Stone Ridge 12484$592k typical value78.3
  15. #906Highland 12528$433k typical value77.6
  16. #954Shokan 12481$455k typical value76.0
  17. #987Pine Hill 12465$412k typical value74.4
  18. #994Hurley 12443$453k typical value74.0
  19. #1041Shandaken 12480$350k typical value71.9
  20. #1044Rosendale 12472$414k typical value71.8
  21. #1046Marlboro 12542$465k typical value71.5
  22. #1054West Shokan 12494$491k typical value70.9
  23. #1064West Park 12493$534k typical value70.5
  24. #1075Modena 12548$456k typical value70.0
  25. #1095Chichester 12416$403k typical value69.2
  26. #1102Kingston 12401$395k typical value68.9
  27. #1120Ellenville 12428$302k typical value67.7
  28. #1130West Hurley 12491$477k typical value67.3
  29. #1132Ruby 1247567.2
  30. #1149Connelly 1241766.2
  31. #1158Highmount 1244166.0
  32. #1166Rifton 1247165.4
  33. #1185High Falls 12440$506k typical value63.8
  34. #1186Glasco 1243263.8
  35. #1204Esopus 1242962.8
  36. #1207Big Indian 12410$404k typical value62.8
  37. #1211Lake Hill 12448$613k typical value62.5
  38. #1222Bloomington 12411$407k typical value62.0
  39. #1233Phoenicia 12464$407k typical value61.3
  40. #1239Malden On Hudson 12453$422k typical value61.2
  41. #1252Claryville 12725$326k typical value60.3
  42. #1272Ulster Park 12487$444k typical value59.0
  43. #1317Willow 12495$650k typical value56.1
  44. #1345Olivebridge 12461$547k typical value54.0
  45. #1353Glenford 12433$561k typical value53.4
  46. #1357Woodstock 12498$659k typical value53.1
  47. #1403Mount Tremper 12457$612k typical value49.8
  48. #1417Saugerties 12477$413k typical value48.7
  49. #1422Gardiner 12525$551k typical value48.0
  50. #1490Clintondale 12515$449k typical value39.9
  51. #1510Kerhonkson 12446$411k typical value36.9
  52. #1536Accord 12404$531k typical value33.4
  53. #1545Bearsville 12409$742k typical value32.0
  54. —Spring Glen 12483—
  55. —Wawarsing 12489$305k typical value—
  56. —West Camp 12490—

See Ulster County ranked your way

Open New York in Abunsh, weight what matters and every ZIP code is re-scored. Free to start.

Open New York in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Each ZIP code is scored against every US ZIP code; places are within New York. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.