Skip to content

Cincinnatus, NY 13040

Property market data for buyers and investors, October 2026 · Cortland County · 2,595 residents (Census 2020–24 survey)

95.6

Area Score

#294 of 1,693 New York ZIP codes

Low confidence · few sales, limited data
Open 13040 in the app
  • Supply63
  • Demand64
  • Home Values99
  • Rental Market79
  • Economics93

Each group scores 0 to 100 against every US ZIP code. By default the Area Score weights supply, demand, values and rents 22.5% each; the local economy 10%. Economics uses county figures (a blend where a ZIP code spans counties). A thin market: fewer than 20 homes sold in 6 months, so a few sales move its figures.

Cortland 13045: Area Score 99.9Homer 13077: Area Score 98.1McGraw 13101: Area Score 95.5Willet 13863: Area Score 95.3Marathon 13803: Area Score 91.9Preble 13141: Area Score 91.4Truxton 13158: Area Score 91.1Harford 13784: Area Score 87.9Little York 13087: Area Score 66.9Blodgett Mills 13738: Area Score —Cincinnatus 13040: Area Score 95.6
Cincinnatus 13040, ringed, with the other ZIP codes of Cortland County.

Typical home value

$179,081

Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,360/mo

HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027); utilities included

Residents

2,595

Census 2020–24 survey

Cincinnatus 13040 at a glance

Cincinnatus 13040 scores 95.6 out of 100 on Abunsh's Area Score at the default weights, #294 of 1,693 scored New York ZIP codes, with Low confidence. Its strongest group is Home Values (99 of 100) and its weakest Supply (63). The typical home value is $179,081, against a median $196,967 across Cortland County. HUD's fair rent for a 3-bedroom home is $1,360 a month.

The 26 indicators behind the score

The default ranking's indicators, each against every US ZIP code with a figure this month.

  • Months of SupplySupply · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Inventory Growth (vs 2019)Supply · Realtor.com®, Oct 2026 against 2019—no national ranking
  • New Homes Approved per 1,000 (county)Supply · Census permits, 12 months to Sep 2026; homes Census 2020–244.8 per 1,000 homes (county)Score 58/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Homes Sold After a Price Cut %Supply · homes sold in the 6 months to Sep 2026, from their listing histories—no national ranking
  • New Supply per SaleSupply · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Housing Stock GrowthSupply · Census 2015–19 to 2020–24-1.3%/yrScore 74/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Share of Homes for SaleSupply · Realtor.com® listings Oct 2026; homes Census 2020–240.7%Score 59/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Under Contract in 2 Weeks %Demand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Sale-to-List RatioDemand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Sold Above List %Demand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Population GrowthDemand · Census estimates, about 2017 to 20250.3%/yrScore 52/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Under Contract per Home for SaleDemand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Housing Shortage GrowthDemand · Census 2015–19 to 2020–24+1.7 pts a yearScore 81/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Home Value Forecast (12-mo)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2026 to Oct 20274.2%Score 98/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Home Value Growth (1-yr)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 20268.4%Score 92/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Sale Price Growth (24-mo trend)Home Values · Redfin, 24 months to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Home Value Growth (5-yr, per year)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2021 to Oct 20266.4%/yrScore 85/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Years of Income to BuyHome Values · Zillow value Oct 2026; incomes Census 2020–242.6 yearsScore 85/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Incomes Gaining on Home ValuesHome Values · Census incomes and Zillow values, 2015–19 to 2020–24-0.9 pts a yearScore 76/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Rent Growth (YoY)Rental Market · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Years of Rent to BuyRental Market · Zillow 3-bed value Oct 2026; HUD 3-bed rent FY2027, moved by Zillow rents11.6 yearsScore 75/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Rents Gaining on Home ValuesRental Market · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Rent Share of Renter IncomeRental Market · HUD 2-bed rent FY2027; renter incomes Census 2020–24—no national ranking
  • Renter Household GrowthRental Market · Census 2015–19 to 2020–241.6%/yrScore 68/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Jobs Outpacing New Homes (county)Economics · jobs to Q1 2026, homes approved to Sep 2026+24.6 per 1,000 homesScore 97/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Unemployment Rate, 12-Month Average (county)Economics · 12 months to Aug 20264.6%Score 35/100 vs US ZIPs

Other ZIP codes in Cortland County

Best placed first. All 11 in Cortland County

  1. #12Cortland 13045$209k typical value99.9
  2. #153Homer 13077$234k typical value98.1
  3. #296McGraw 13101$178k typical value95.5
  4. #306Willet 13863$157k typical value95.3
  5. #453Marathon 13803$204k typical value91.9
  6. #480Preble 13141$224k typical value91.4
  7. #495Truxton 13158$197k typical value91.1
  8. #610Harford 13784$179k typical value87.9
  9. #1136Little York 1308766.9
  10. —Blodgett Mills 13738—

See Cincinnatus 13040 ranked your way

Weight what matters and open your top 5 in New York free. Cincinnatus 13040's own Value, Economics and Trends come with a paid plan.

Open in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Places are within New York. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.