Skip to content

Ohio data · October 2026

Carroll County, Ohio property market data

Abunsh scores 8 of the 10 ZIP codes in Carroll County against every US ZIP code for supply, demand, home values, the rental market and the local economy. The Area Score's Economics group uses county figures, so ZIP codes wholly inside Carroll County share them; one that spans counties blends them. The best placed is Sherrodsville 44675, #216 of 1,153 in Ohio. The typical home value is a median $229,141 across the county's ZIP codes.

ZIP codes

10

8 scored · October 2026

Best Area Score

91.7

Sherrodsville 44675

Typical home value

$229k

Median of ZIP codes · Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,305/mo

Median of ZIP codes · HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027)

Top markets in Carroll County

The best-placed ZIP codes with Very High or High confidence, at the default ranking: 2 of 10. Places are within Ohio.

Sherrodsville 44675: Area Score 91.7Amsterdam 43903: Area Score 89.3Bowerston 44695: Area Score 88.1Carrollton 44615: Area Score 84.6Magnolia 44643: Area Score 84.2Mechanicstown 44651: Area Score 70.2Dellroy 44620: Area Score 70.2Malvern 44644: Area Score 36.1Augusta 44607: Area Score —Leesville 44639: Area Score —
Carroll County's ZIP codes in Ohio, colored by Area Score.
  1. #405Carrollton 44615$179k typical value84.6
  2. #1069Malvern 44644$275k typical value36.1

Every ZIP code in Carroll County

Best placed first, each with its Area Score.

  1. #216Sherrodsville 44675$224k typical value91.7
  2. #285Amsterdam 43903$119k typical value89.3
  3. #309Bowerston 44695$171k typical value88.1
  4. #405Carrollton 44615$179k typical value84.6
  5. #413Magnolia 44643$238k typical value84.2
  6. #687Mechanicstown 44651$234k typical value70.2
  7. #691Dellroy 44620$252k typical value70.2
  8. #1069Malvern 44644$275k typical value36.1
  9. —Augusta 44607—
  10. —Leesville 44639—

See Carroll County ranked your way

Open Ohio in Abunsh, weight what matters and every ZIP code is re-scored. Free to start.

Open Ohio in Abunsh

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Each ZIP code is scored against every US ZIP code; places are within Ohio. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.