Best Rental Property Markets in Ohio
Abunsh scores 1,195 Ohio ZIP codes on 12 leading supply and demand signals and ranks them with a national-percentile Combined Signal Score. Across the state, the typical home value is $220K, the median gross rental yield is 8.7%, and homes sit a median of 54 days on market. Data reflects June 2026.
Top Ohio markets right now
Ranked by the default Combined Signal Score (Very High + High confidence). Showing the top 15 — open the free app to see all 1,195 and re-rank by your own priorities.
| # | ZIP | City | County | Score | Gross Yield | Days to Close | Typical Value | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 44710 | Canton | Stark | 89 | 11.03% | 42d | $128K | Very High |
| 2 | 44902 | Mansfield | Richland | 87 | 15.10% | 58d | $84K | High |
| 3 | 44142 | Brookpark | Cuyahoga | 87 | 10.39% | 46d | $220K | Very High |
| 4 | 44130 | Cleveland | Cuyahoga | 86 | 9.94% | 40d | $242K | Very High |
| 5 | 44117 | Euclid | Cuyahoga | 86 | 11.32% | 58d | $158K | Very High |
| 6 | 44135 | Cleveland | Cuyahoga | 85 | 11.64% | 45d | $156K | Very High |
| 7 | 44137 | Maple Heights | Cuyahoga | 85 | 15.00% | 55d | $126K | Very High |
| 8 | 44706 | Canton | Stark | 85 | 10.45% | 45d | $152K | Very High |
| 9 | 44830 | Fostoria | Seneca | 85 | 10.33% | 58d | $149K | Very High |
| 10 | 44111 | Cleveland | Cuyahoga | 85 | 10.28% | 48d | $179K | Very High |
| 11 | 44060 | Mentor | Lake | 84 | 9.66% | 47d | $261K | Very High |
| 12 | 44144 | Cleveland | Cuyahoga | 84 | 10.28% | 43d | $187K | Very High |
| 13 | 44092 | Wickliffe | Lake | 83 | 10.33% | 49d | $203K | Very High |
| 14 | 44125 | Cleveland | Cuyahoga | 83 | 13.01% | 68d | $139K | Very High |
| 15 | 45414 | Dayton | Montgomery | 83 | 9.28% | 56d | $213K | Very High |
Best Ohio ZIP codes for rental yield
Highest gross rental yield among confidently-scored ZIPs.
- 44507 (Youngstown) — 19.61% gross yield, typical value $54K
- 43608 (Toledo) — 18.32% gross yield, typical value $55K
- 43605 (Toledo) — 17.78% gross yield, typical value $69K
- 44127 (Cleveland) — 16.89% gross yield, typical value $60K
- 44502 (Youngstown) — 16.61% gross yield, typical value $69K
Fastest-moving Ohio markets
Strongest 9-month price momentum among confidently-scored ZIPs.
- 45814 (Arlington) — 55.80% 9-month price momentum
- 45804 (Lima) — 51.72% 9-month price momentum
- 45663 (West Portsmouth) — 51.01% 9-month price momentum
- 44127 (Cleveland) — 49.06% 9-month price momentum
- 44112 (Cleveland) — 48.08% 9-month price momentum
Browse Ohio by county
88 counties with scored ZIP codes.
Rank Ohio markets by your own strategy
Open the free app to re-rank all 12 leading signals by what matters to you and see every location rescored. No signup required.
Combined Signal Score is a national percentile ranking on the default signal order; in the free app you can re-rank all 12 signals to your own strategy and every location is rescored. Figures describe market data for June 2026 and are informational only — not investment advice.