Skip to content

Kelleys Island, OH 43438

Property market data for buyers and investors, October 2026 · Erie County · 128 residents (Census 2020–24 survey)

22.9

Area Score

#1133 of 1,153 Ohio ZIP codes · #16 of 18 in Sandusky metro

Low confidence · few sales, limited data
Open 43438 in the app
  • Supply60
  • Demand16
  • Home Values84
  • Rental Market6
  • Economics5

Each group scores 0 to 100 against every US ZIP code. By default the Area Score weights supply, demand, values and rents 22.5% each; the local economy 10%. Economics uses county figures (a blend where a ZIP code spans counties). A thin market: fewer than 20 homes sold in 6 months, so a few sales move its figures.

Sandusky 44870: Area Score 90.1Vermilion 44089: Area Score 86.2Castalia 44824: Area Score 83.0Milan 44846: Area Score 65.0Huron 44839: Area Score 62.4Berlin Heights 44814: Area Score 20.7Kelleys Island 43438: Area Score 22.9
Kelleys Island 43438, ringed, with the other ZIP codes of Erie County.

Typical home value

$433,121

Zillow Home Value Index, October 2026

Fair rent, 3-bed

$1,530/mo

HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent, 3 bedrooms, FY2027 (Oct 2026 to Sep 2027); utilities included

Residents

128

Census 2020–24 survey

Kelleys Island 43438 at a glance

Kelleys Island 43438 scores 22.9 out of 100 on Abunsh's Area Score at the default weights, #1133 of 1,153 scored Ohio ZIP codes and #16 of 18 in Sandusky metro, with Low confidence. Its strongest group is Home Values (84 of 100) and its weakest Economics (5). The typical home value is $433,121, against a median $272,670 across Erie County. HUD's fair rent for a 3-bedroom home is $1,530 a month.

The 26 indicators behind the score

The default ranking's indicators, each against every US ZIP code with a figure this month.

  • Months of SupplySupply · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Inventory Growth (vs 2019)Supply · Realtor.com®, Oct 2026 against 2019-60.7% vs 2019Score 93/100 vs US ZIPs
  • New Homes Approved per 1,000 (county)Supply · Census permits, 12 months to Sep 2026; homes Census 2020–244.5 per 1,000 homes (county)Score 59/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Homes Sold After a Price Cut %Supply · homes sold in the 6 months to Sep 2026, from their listing histories—no national ranking
  • New Supply per SaleSupply · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Housing Stock GrowthSupply · Census 2015–19 to 2020–242.2%/yrScore 19/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Share of Homes for SaleSupply · Realtor.com® listings Oct 2026; homes Census 2020–240.9%Score 43/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Under Contract in 2 Weeks %Demand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Sale-to-List RatioDemand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Sold Above List %Demand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Population GrowthDemand · Census estimates, about 2017 to 2025—no national ranking
  • Under Contract per Home for SaleDemand · Redfin, Aug–Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Housing Shortage GrowthDemand · Census 2015–19 to 2020–24-14.8 pts a yearScore 0/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Home Value Forecast (12-mo)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2026 to Oct 20274.0%Score 97/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Home Value Growth (1-yr)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 20263.8%Score 63/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Sale Price Growth (24-mo trend)Home Values · Redfin, 24 months to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Home Value Growth (5-yr, per year)Home Values · Zillow, Oct 2021 to Oct 20265.4%/yrScore 70/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Years of Income to BuyHome Values · Zillow value Oct 2026; incomes Census 2020–245.2 yearsScore 21/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Incomes Gaining on Home ValuesHome Values · Census incomes and Zillow values, 2015–19 to 2020–24-0.3 pts a yearScore 81/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Rent Growth (YoY)Rental Market · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Years of Rent to BuyRental Market · Zillow 3-bed value Oct 2026; HUD 3-bed rent FY2027, moved by Zillow rents26.1 yearsScore 5/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Rents Gaining on Home ValuesRental Market · Zillow, Oct 2025 to Oct 2026—no national ranking
  • Rent Share of Renter IncomeRental Market · HUD 2-bed rent FY2027; renter incomes Census 2020–24—no national ranking
  • Renter Household GrowthRental Market · Census 2015–19 to 2020–24—no national ranking
  • Jobs Outpacing New Homes (county)Economics · jobs to Q1 2026, homes approved to Sep 2026-37.2 per 1,000 homesScore 8/100 vs US ZIPs
  • Unemployment Rate, 12-Month Average (county)Economics · 12 months to Aug 20264.4%Score 43/100 vs US ZIPs

Other ZIP codes in Erie County

Best placed first. All 7 in Erie County

  1. #265Sandusky 44870$185k typical value90.1
  2. #362Vermilion 44089$271k typical value86.2
  3. #443Castalia 44824$243k typical value83.0
  4. #774Milan 44846$285k typical value65.0
  5. #806Huron 44839$307k typical value62.4
  6. #1138Berlin Heights 44814$273k typical value20.7

See Kelleys Island 43438 ranked your way

Weight what matters and open your top 5 in Ohio free. Kelleys Island 43438's own Value, Economics and Trends come with a paid plan.

Open in Abunsh

Or see it in its metro: Sandusky metro.

The month's biggest movers, by email

One email a month when new data lands: the ZIP codes whose Area Score rose most, Very High and High confidence only. Unsubscribe in one click.

We keep your email only to send the briefing; see the privacy policy. Market data, not financial advice.

Figures describe October 2026 data. Places are within Ohio and Sandusky metro. The Area Score describes market data at Abunsh's default weights; it is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any property and is not financial advice. Typical home values: Data Provided by Zillow Group. County jobs and unemployment: BLS. BLS.gov cannot vouch for the data or analyses derived from these data after the data have been retrieved from BLS.gov. County homes approved and population: U.S. Census Bureau. How the score works.